Redeem the Time

Thomism Is

with 4 comments

In my experience, Thomists of the strict observance believe that Thomism is the hardware that will run any software. And increasingly I have come to suspect that they just may be right. That worthy Dominican, Father Benedict Ashley, somewhere writes that a distinctive contribution of Thomas to the Christian tradition was his insistence that study and the intellectual life are not merely means to an end but an almost sacramental means of the end itself, which is our sanctification. In this way, too, it is the case that to be an educated Catholic is to be in some important sense a Thomist.

-Father Neuhaus, On the Square

The hardware that will run any software. Hah!

In some ways I like the metaphor, but too much software—too much “Catholic” software—is designed so that it won’t run on Thomist hardware. Yet I suppose that sort of software isn’t really software at all. Rather, these are viruses of the trojan horse variety that try to ruin the hardware, or annoying adware and pop-ups that never cease their attempts to prevent you from doing anything with it.

The hollow charges of “rationalism,” hurled against St. Thomas by those who don’t understand him, need to stop if theology wants to be theology again. Hell, you need to understand St. Thomas even if you want to “change culture” and “speak to the modern world” and all the other things that modern theology is always talking about but never doing. Anyhow, its nice to hear the truth—to be an educated Catholic is to be a Thomist in some important sense, but not many Catholics know or admit that. Which makes one wonder how many Catholics are educated.

I am a tired Catholic who needs to go to sleep. Researching land use policy has that effect sometimes. Other times it can be interesting, but then again we must remember that truth and goodness (and beauty—is it kosher for me to say that?) are convertible with being, so anything can be interesting given a nature that naturally desires to know.

Written by kodiakisland

June 2, 2006 at 2:34 am

Posted in Thomism

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Reminds me of a quote by Chesterton:

    “The fact that Thomism is the philosophy of common sense is itself a matter of common sense.”

    Advocatus Militaris

    June 2, 2006 at 4:56 pm

  2. Ugh. I love St. Thomas. His works are landmark, clear, and beautiful. But all Catholics have to be Thomists? Nah. There are beautiful traditions in the Franciscan order (a la Bonaventure, and Duns Scotus to some degree) or even an examination of the Jesuit Suarez can be fruitful in terms of Theology. Even the mystical Theology of Catherine of Sienna or St. John of the Cross is worth examination by an educated Catholic. Sure, an educated Catholic should be familiar – or more – with St. Thomas.
    But something about calling oneself a Thomist in the Catholic (that is – Universal) Church I find alarming. We should put aside petty sectarian disputing and embrace all of the ways in which God has chosen to use His servants to teach us about Himself.

    beitiathustra

    June 2, 2006 at 6:40 pm

  3. Not that I am Catholic, but I agree with beitiathustra nearly word for word.

    That doesn’t happen much. ;)

    andrew.simone

    June 3, 2006 at 2:07 pm

  4. Just saw this now, and I have to say that I agree with the post that, to some extent, to be an educated Catholic is to be Thomist. This doesn’t mean that Thomism per se is dogma, but rather, that Thomism is the best and most systematic portrait of the Faith we have thus far…

    indignus

    October 26, 2007 at 11:58 am


Leave a Reply